Cafe Reviews/New York/Third Rail Coffee

Third Rail Coffee

240 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012

Reviewed by Chris JordanSeptember 2025

Location

Loading Map...

Overall Score Score: 8.3 out of 10
8.3
Overall Score
Coffee Score: 8.5 out of 10
8.5
Coffee
Atmosphere Score: 8 out of 10
8.0
Atmosphere
Service Score: 8.5 out of 10
8.5
Service
Vibe Score8.0 / 10

The Story

Founded in 2009, this Greenwich Village cafe quickly became a staple for coffee lovers seeking quality and community. Their mission is to bring exceptional coffee and genuine hospitality to the neighborhood, fostering connections over expertly crafted drinks. Over the years, they've built a loyal following and contributed to New York's third wave coffee scene. Their continued commitment to consistency and warmth has made them a beloved local fixture.

Craft & Expertise

Baristas here are known for their precise, consistent espresso shots and skillful milk work, serving up drinks with balanced flavor and beautiful presentation. The coffee menu is focused and curated, with rotating single-origin options and a few standout signature drinks. Every cup is prepared with care, whether you're ordering a classic cortado or a pour-over. The space is compact, with a handful of seats and a standing bar, encouraging quick chats or a brief respite. Drinks are served in sturdy ceramic or takeaway cups, always with attention to detail.

What Sets This Cafe Apart

What truly distinguishes this cafe is its unwavering dedication to both craft and community. The staff's genuine friendliness and memory for regulars' orders create a sense of belonging that's rare in the city. The minimalist, no-frills design keeps the focus on quality coffee and authentic interactions. It's a place that feels like a local secret, even as it draws coffee aficionados from across New York.