Butler

95 S 5th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Reviewed by Chris JordanSeptember 2025

Location

Loading Map...

Overall Score Score: 8.3 out of 10
8.3
Overall Score
Coffee Score: 8.5 out of 10
8.5
Coffee
Atmosphere Score: 8 out of 10
8.0
Atmosphere
Service Score: 8.5 out of 10
8.5
Service
Vibe Score8.0 / 10

The Story

Born from a desire to merge culinary excellence with specialty coffee, this cafe quickly became a staple in Brooklyn's vibrant food scene. The team set out to create a welcoming space where the artistry of baking and brewing could shine side by side. Over the years, they've earned a loyal following and recognition for their innovative approach to cafe fare. Their vision is to elevate everyday rituals, making each visit a memorable experience that connects the community.

Craft & Expertise

Every cup here is brewed with precision, using carefully sourced beans and a deep respect for technique. The baristas are skilled and attentive, consistently delivering balanced espresso and velvety milk textures. Signature drinks, like their seasonal lattes, showcase both creativity and technical mastery. Coffee is served in elegant ceramics, enhancing the sensory experience whether you're seated at the marble-topped bar or a cozy window nook. The attention to detail is evident from the first sip to the last.

What Sets This Cafe Apart

What truly distinguishes Butler is its chef-driven pastry program, which rivals the best bakeries in the city and pairs seamlessly with their coffee offerings. The interior design strikes a rare balance between sophisticated and approachable, making it equally suited for work or leisure. Their commitment to culinary innovation is matched by a genuine hospitality that makes every guest feel valued. It's a destination that redefines what a neighborhood cafe can be.